YNW Melly – Melly Vs. Melvin (Album Review)


YNW Melly (aka Jamell Demons) plays a deranged, but talented musician in “Melly Vs. Melvin.”




5. 223’S

I think YNW Melly is f**ked up in the head. As the Florida rapper fights for his freedom after being charged with murder, he continues to drop music that talks about shooting n***as (SMH). “223s,” a song that features Glokknine, is YNW’s latest form of incriminating evidence.

In “223s,” YNW Melly sings about homicide, homicide, and more homicide. While I am obviously not the biggest fan of the content attached to the song, I do f**k with the 90’s R&B-inspired melody YNW was able to deliver on it. I also f**k with GlokkNine’s gritty ass verse on the song, too (I’m assuming he is not a real killer, so his part doesn’t bother me that much).

If YNW Melly was walking towards me in the streets, I would tuck my wallet.




“Waitin On You” is absolutely beautiful! On it, YNW Melly sings soulfully about how he’s waiting for Jesus to save him from all of his misery (Hold on, an alleged murderer named Jamell Demons made a song about Jesus?).

Tonk Wit Tha Gift (a n***a with one of the most interesting rap names I’ve ever heard) is featured on “Waitin On You,” and on his verse on the track, he gifts us with raw ass bars about changing his drug-dealing/gang-banging ways.

While I love both the serious harmonizing and infectious melody YNW gifts us with on “Waitin On You,” it’s the song’s instrumental that blows me away the most (How the hell was the person that made this beat able to trapify Michael Jackson’s “Human Nature” beat?).




YNW Melly does his best impersonation of Young Thug in “Adam Sandler:” On the track, he drops a very Thugger-esque hook, and sings like Thugger over a Thugger-esque instrumental.

So what is “Adam Sandler” about? Unfortunately, it’s not about Wedding Singers or bad golfers; instead, it’s about putting n***as in their places, living life like a king, and getting dome from chicks that ugly n***as probably don’t deserve.




For those that don’t know, YNW Melly has three personalities: Melly, Marcus, and Melvin. all three are crazy, but one is crazy crazy (Melvin)! Anywho, in “Two Face,” YNW lets the world know that all three of his sides are violent, horny, and vengeful.

“Two Face” is powered by this gentle instrumental that sounds like it has low blood pressure. Over this instrumental, YNW Melly sings serenely, womanly, and grungily. It’s your job to figure out which side of Melly is the womanly singer…




“Suicidal” is special! Matter of fact, on it, I believe YNW Melly reaches his potential as a singer.

In “Suicidal,” you get a version of YNW Melly that is pretty f**king heartbroken. Throughout the track, the Florida rapper sings emotionally about a girl doing him wrong, and how that has had an impact on his life. When it’s all said and done, I love the melody Melly gifts us with on this song, in addition to the fearless harmonizing he does throughout.

So I guess a girl turned Melly into a cold-blooded n***a?


1. TWO FACE (4/5)

2. SUICIDAL (5/5)


4. BANG BANG (3.5/5)

5. BILLBOARD (4/5)

6. I AINT LYING (3.5/5)

7. I’M A STAR (3/5)

8. MY SLIME (3.5/5)

9. 100K (3.5/5)



12. STAY UP (3.5/5)

13. WAITIN ON YOU (4/5)

14. 223s (4/5)




I hate to say it, but YNW Melly is a talented ass rapper/singer! Not only is he great at creating melodies that are infectious/soul-clinching, but he also has a knack for making ordinary trap songs poke out like Meagan Good’s ass at a country club.

Lets be real about a few things regarding this album:

  1. YNW Melly sounds like Young Thug. Don’t get me wrong, Thugger is more unpredictable than YNW; however, for the most part, both rappers are erratic ass music-makers. With that being said, in “Melly Vs. Melvin,” you get instrumentals that Thugger would rap over, in addition to deranged singing throughout (Young Thug is the king of deranged singing).
  2. It’s disturbing as s**t listening toYNW Melly talk about shooting people on this album. As you may know, he’s in jail for allegedly murdering two people, so more than likely, what he’s talking about in this album is s**t he’s done/or wouldn’t mind doing. With that being said, do not listen to this album at night.
  3. Real n***as won’t admit it, but YNW Melly has a pretty solid voice. No, he’s not the second-coming of Lionel Ritchie, but he does know how to hold notes that great singers know how to hold (I know what I said, folks). Taking what I said into consideration, you will love the songs in which YNW opens up about heartbreak and love on this album.

There are moments in which “Melly Vs. Melvin” blows me away, and then there are moments in which the album falls in line with the other s**t I hear on the radio today. With Melly looking at the possibility of being sentenced to death, I find it extremely sad that we may never get to hear him make a full album in which he blows me away… Oh well!

2 replies »

  1. I give it an F. The album is totally commercial, it feels like they took all of mellys passed flopped songs and put them in a floppy disk and constructed it to sound nothing but R&B popish, wich again is obviously not at all what melly is. The beats where terrible the content is boring and the whole album seems to be not genuine in a time where all he needs is in fact TRUTH. I missed his honest pationisnt gritty witty word play and subliminal inuendos over amazing trap beats and dead on spot collaboration. To me an album from a person awaiting trial for capital murder who doesn’t even mentions it is not an album its a plea. They left out if not the best certainly the closest song to momm1 & momm2 “mind of a maniac” is an obvious choice of his legal team. Overall melly sounded alone abandon and really sad but hey what do you expect from someone that doesn’t even have the respect to take his 2 best friends to the hospital or at least show up at a later time right.

    • first and foremost, thanks for reading 🙏🏾! Secondly, thanks for the comment!

      You make great points! I did think the album sounded a bit commercial, but I think commercial is a good look for YNW (you call it sloppy, I call it growth lol). I do admit, Melly’s content could’ve been better, but I disagree with you on the beats; they were fire! As for him addressing his case, I’m not sure when the songs were recorded (Before or after his case), but I do feel like he insinuates that’s he’s in some deep s**t here and there in the album. Believe it or not, I liked the fact he didn’t talk about his trial.

      In the end of the day, Melly is a scary ass dude that is in some deep s**t. If he did what he’s being accused of, geez is my only response…

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.