Benny The Butcher fires from all cylinders in “Summertime Butch 2.”
STREAM
TOP 5
5. Pandoras (Ft. ElCamino & Duckman)
I feel like we don’t appreciate posse cuts enough in 2025. “Pandoras” is a very strong one. ElCamino, Duckman, and Benny The Butcher are on the same wavelength, dropping bars about street loyalty, life lessons, and motivation—all while delivering excellent raps flawlessly over mafioso-style production. They also hit us with fantastic punchlines and solid storytelling throughout. I swear to God, if this track had dropped in 1998, it would’ve made its way onto one of those HITS compilation albums.
4. In The Wall (Ft. Bun B)
The beat behind “In The Wall” is absolutely wild—it sounds like some s**t straight out of a cartoon multiverse. It’s colorful, chaotic, and undeniably attention-grabbing. Over this unpredictable soundscape, Benny The Butcher delivers one of his most energetic performances in recent memory. His flow is quick as hell and explosive, filled with sharp-tongued bars about his resilience, his disgust for weak rappers, and stacks of untaxed drug money.
Then Bun B comes through with a surprisingly perfect verse that might actually fit the beat better than Benny’s. He brings his classic Southern drawl, dripping with wisdom and grit, as he reminisces on his past in the drug game and his bond with Benny. The chemistry between the two feels natural, which you’ll love to hear.
3. Why Would I (Ft. G Herbo)
If someone told me “Why Would I” is the best track on this album, I wouldn’t argue one bit. This record showcases Benny in top-tier form, flexing a flow that’s both slippery and surgical. Lyrically, he unloads bars aimed at less capable rappers and touches on themes of betrayal and loyalty. Additionally, the chorus he laces between verses is raw, real, and dripping with that street-certified charisma that Chet Holmgreen would want in his veins.
G Herbo sounds like he recorded his verse while hooked up to a ventilator on this track. While some may feel his presence disrupts the otherwise airtight vibe, his verse does bring a different texture. Still, it’s Benny who steals the show here, so let’s move on.
2. Summertime ’25
Benny the Butcher empties the clip when it comes to punchlines in this freestyle-sounding banger.
Driven by a cinematic, violin-laced instrumental, “Summer 25” showcases Benny’s signature blend of gritty realism and lyrical mastery. On the track, he delivers pointed bars about the current state of hip-hop, references the Oklahoma City Thunder’s recent NBA championship, and reflects on his persistent ties to the street hustle. His tone is unbothered, steady, and unapologetic—In other words, Benny raps like he never left the hood or the booth.
1. Told You So (Ft. Mike WILL Made-It)
I don’t think this project has a traditional studio album feel, but “Told You So” is one of those tracks that could fit seamlessly on one. Produced by Mike Will Made It, the beat is striking and dramatic, laced with a solid tempo and these ambient elements that make it feel like it’s walking a tightrope between heartwarming and icy. This gives just enough space for Benny the Butcher to lay into his performance. The hook he delivers gives off a vintage feel—something you could easily imagine J. Cole throwing on a mixtape.
Benny approaches the verses with his signature aggression and lyrical precision, recounting his grind, setbacks, and the relentless hunger that continues to fuel his rise. This is the kind of track that will make you toss a few dollars in Benny’s GoFundMe plate.
SONG-BY-SONG RATING
1. Summer Feelin’ Intro (N/A)
Become an RGM+ Member!
Want to know what rating we gave each track? Subscribe below!
RGM RATING
(78%)
Benny The Butcher doesn’t carry himself like a modern-day rapper—and that’s intentional. Everything about his aesthetic screams ’90s mafioso rap, as if he traveled to 2025 via time machine. His demeanor, delivery, and beat selection all reflect an era when raw storytelling and street codes dominated hip-hop. That nostalgia-driven style comes through loud and clear on Summertime Butch 2, a project that feels like a gritty throwback without sounding dated.
On this tape, Benny spits over the kind of soulful, hard-knocking production you might’ve heard Jay-Z tear through in his early days. His subject matter is equally classic: unapologetic tales of drug dealing, street survival, and loyalty codes, all delivered with the cool detachment of someone who’s lived it. The authenticity in Benny’s bars isn’t just aesthetic—it’s the engine that drives the entire project, anchoring it in a raw, street-rooted realism that never chases trends.
What also elevates Summertime Butch 2 is the company Benny keeps. He enlists guest features from artists who know how to shine in the lane of street rap, enhancing the album’s grimy texture without overshadowing his voice. At the same time, Benny continues to sidestep the commercial sounds that someone of his stature could easily tap into, choosing instead to double down on what he does best. This project isn’t just a showcase of skill—it’s a statement. This is what you should want from your street rapper.
Quincy is the creator of Ratings Game Music. He loves writing about music, taking long walks on beaches, and spaghetti that fights him back.
