Taylor Swift – The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore (Album Review)

Taylor Swift delivers catchy pop and warns against nostalgia on “The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore.“


STREAM


“ENCORE” TRACKS, RANKED:

4. Cleveland!

“Cleveland!” is incredibly cute. Taylor Swift has previously described her songwriting through three different types of pens. Fountain pen songs combine modern storytelling with poetic details, quill pen songs draw inspiration from history, and glitter gel pen songs are created purely for fun. “Cleveland!” is the definition of a glitter gel pen song. It never takes itself too seriously and perfectly captures the playful spirit of The Life of a Showgirl.

Much of the instrumental consists of bright, poppy synths inspired by wedding bells. Over them, Taylor addresses the many criticisms her haters throw in her direction. She does not seem bothered by their comments and may even agree with some of them. Ultimately, none of those opinions matter because her “baby”—Kansas City Chiefs tight end Travis Kelce—“likes what he likes.” Fortunately for Taylor, what he likes is her, questionable dancing and all.

3. Babylon

“Babylon” explores the danger of allowing nostalgia to distract you from the present. The song’s subject is so consumed by memories of the past that beautiful experiences continue slipping away unnoticed. Taylor summarizes that message perfectly in the chorus, realizing something was “Babylon ’til it was gone.”

Although the track is unmistakably pop, its instrumental contains some lovely country influences. Taylor’s closing songs often express the central idea of an entire project, and “Babylon” serves as a fitting thesis for both The Encore and The Life of a Showgirl: remain present and appreciate the beauty surrounding you before it disappears. That message connects naturally with the deluxe edition’s other three additions, but it also complements songs from the original album, including “Ruin the Friendship,” “Wi$h Li$t,” and “Honey.”

2. Pink Clouding

I love a good Taylor Swift apology song, and “Pink Clouding” fits that category perfectly. Taylor addresses an ex whom she used as a rebound after escaping a toxic relationship. She acknowledges that she became the toxic person in their partnership, recognizes that he deserved better, and sincerely hopes that life has treated him well since their breakup.

To me, “Pink Clouding” sounds like an apology connected to “Getaway Car” and British actor Tom Hiddleston. On that track, Taylor admits that she entered the relationship while running away from someone else, leaving him unaware of what he was truly stepping into. “Pink Clouding” appears to revisit that situation with greater maturity and remorse. The song manages to feel catchy, sad, and hopeful simultaneously. Sonically, it is a polished pop record that would have fit comfortably on her 2019 album, Lover.


1. Patient Zero

“Patient Zero” centers on a woman contacting Taylor about problems she is experiencing with one of Taylor’s exes. Rather than treating her like competition, Taylor immediately supports the woman and compares their experiences with the same person. Taylor describes herself as “patient zero” because she encountered his harmful behavior before the women who came after her.

Sonically, the song is incredibly interesting. It opens with gorgeous strings that resemble the beginning of a folk track before quickly shifting into pop. Those strings remain woven throughout the arrangement, becoming one layer within an otherwise busy mix. There are plenty of sounds competing for attention, yet everything works together beautifully. The bridge becomes especially wordy, but in a playful and effective way. It sounds like Taylor is having casual “girl talk” over the phone, creating a conversational contrast with the longer, more drawn-out melodies heard throughout the rest of the song.


SONG BY SONG RATING

Patient Zero (4.5/5)

Cleveland! (3/5)

Pink Clouding (4.5/5)

Babylon (4/5)


RGM RATING

Rating: 4 out of 5.

The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore is a solid collection of songs and a natural continuation of The Life of a Showgirl in every way. It delivers undeniably catchy Max Martin pop, and as “Cleveland!” makes clear, Taylor and Travis remain very happy together.

In my opinion, these songs actually strengthen The Life of a Showgirl conceptually by making its central theme much clearer. The album is about living in the present, appreciating the beautiful moments as fully as possible, and recognizing bad situations for what they are so that you can escape them. That message did not completely come together for me until these new songs expanded upon it in different ways.

“Patient Zero” is about identifying red flags as they appear and later helping someone else recognize them. “Pink Clouding” explores how Taylor’s past prevented her from being a good partner in another relationship. “Babylon” captures the project’s entire theme within one song. “Cleveland!” is the only track that does not follow that idea, choosing instead to be silly, sweet, and carefree.

Compared to the album as a whole, “Patient Zero” and “Pink Clouding” already rank among my favorites. I wonder whether this marks the finale of the Showgirl era. I have a feeling it could usher in some vault-related announcements on October 13, a date Taylor has repeatedly hinted at. In the meantime, I’ll be blasting “Patient Zero.”


Loading poll ...


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

You Might Also Like

Popular Posts

Future’s “Ya Hit” enters the Hot 100 alongside Drake, Travis Scott, and Loe Shimmy features.
JoeJas delivers aggressive, cocky bars over fierce production with softer touches on “BANDIT’S MANIFESTO.”
Xzibit, Redman, and B-Real deliver punchy verses over cinematic production with an old-school California groove.
A dark-tinted pop gem that simply begs to be played out loud and on repeat.