The Odds Are Not in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping’s Favor (Movie Review)


“The Hunger Games” franchise has been in a strange and somewhat confounding spot for the better part of a decade. The adaptations of Suzanne Collins’ YA dystopian novels proved enormously popular, with the Jennifer Lawrence-led original films becoming defining releases for a generation in the early 2010s. Since those films concluded, most of the dystopian YA adaptations that followed have fallen by the wayside. And yet The Hunger Games persists, with Collins expanding the canon through prequels focused on established characters. Lionsgate has been more than happy to bring those stories to the screen, resulting in two largely standalone prequel films, the latest being Sunrise on the Reaping.

That approach bucks conventional wisdom about modern franchise-building, but it isn’t necessarily a bad thing. In fact, the previous film, The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, excelled partly for that reason. Free from the obligation to set up direct sequels, it could tell its own story—and was better for it. The question surrounding this Haymitch-focused prequel, then, isn’t whether Sunrise on the Reaping is essential viewing for the franchise as a whole, but whether it succeeds on its own merits. Unfortunately, the answer is more complicated than it should be.


TOP FIVE THINGS ABOUT “SUNRISE ON THE REAPING

5. The Production is Stellar

The first thing that deserves praise is the production design. Uli Hanisch gives this earlier version of Panem a look rooted in the retro aesthetics of the psychedelic ’70s, and it absolutely rules. Director Francis Lawrence and his go-to cinematographer, Jo Willems, accentuate those details through lighting, staging, and composition, but the sheer consistency of Hanisch’s artistry is jaw-dropping.

Considering this is the sixth Hunger Games film and the fifth Lawrence has directed, the shift in visual influences must have offered him as refreshing a change of pace as it does the audience. For long stretches, Sunrise on the Reaping looks unlike any other film in the franchise, and it’s all the more exciting for it.

4. A Janky Structure

Unfortunately, the writing and narrative structure of Sunrise on the Reaping don’t provide the support its bold visuals deserve. Written by franchise veterans Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie, the screenplay certainly demonstrates familiarity with the source material—more on that in a minute—but its efforts to condense so much of Collins’ prequel novel into a single film work to its detriment.

As it attempts to balance the many characters and relationships surrounding Haymitch, played here by Joseph Zada, the movie becomes episodic and, at times, repetitive, especially once the Games begin. The result is a series of awkward stops and starts that makes it difficult to stay invested in the dozen-plus relationships its protagonist is juggling. That crowded storytelling also contributes to a lengthy runtime that feels less like a feature and more like a bug.



3. Much More of the Same

Even if you go into Sunrise on the Reaping unaware that its filmmakers have several Hunger Games movies under their belts, their familiarity with the franchise quickly becomes painfully obvious. Despite centering on such an offbeat, unpredictable character—Woody Harrelson played him in the original films, for crying out loud—the movie repeatedly falls back on the series’ most well-worn tropes.

It tries to have its cake and eat it too, following the traditional narrative structure of the early films while borrowing from The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, which deliberately stretched its story beyond the arena. The result is a half-measure of both approaches that feels like a Hunger Games greatest-hits compilation. I have no doubt that will work for some viewers, but far too much of the film feels familiar from beginning to end.

2. Great Ensemble

Watching the first hour or so of Sunrise on the Reaping is a surreal experience. Every five to ten minutes, another insanely talented actor appears in a relatively minor role and proceeds to steal the next several scenes. Glenn Close, Billy Porter, Jesse Plemons, Kieran Culkin, Elle Fanning, and Ralph Fiennes make up a bona fide murderer’s row of elite performers, each stepping in as a pinch hitter.

But having these actors breathe such vivid life into their scenes leaves lead Joseph Zada with an unenviable task. He’s already saddled with some of the film’s clunkiest dialogue—everything surrounding Haymitch’s rebellious aspirations could have used several more passes, as it’s so blunt and surface-level that it borders on farce—and he doesn’t yet have the chops to consistently hold his own opposite that lineup.

And who would? Still, this is a film whose emotional core and themes supposedly rest on Haymitch’s shoulders. When so much of its runtime finds the focus pulled toward more compelling supporting characters and performances, it exposes a central disconnect: a movie built around Haymitch too often makes everyone around him more interesting.

1. An Ending That Cannibalizes Itself

The extent to which Sunrise on the Reaping is a “prequel” prequel cannot be overstated. This isn’t simply a film about Haymitch; it feels compelled to explain how he learned to straighten his hair and why he has a gap in his teeth in the original movies.

The film strains to connect itself to the mainline franchise far more explicitly than its immediate predecessor, but the ending brings that impulse full circle in the worst way. Rather than conclude at a moment that would have served the story and driven home its larger theme, it lumbers on for another half-hour, tying up loose ends and steering everything toward the existing films.

That makes the final stretch a slog while robbing Sunrise on the Reaping of the chance to stand on its own. The movie seems convinced that explaining other installments and serving as a companion piece are among its primary responsibilities. In prioritizing those obligations over the needs of its own story, it cannibalizes itself.


RGM GRADE

(C-)

Sunrise on the Reaping is a competently assembled film with stellar production design, standout ensemble performances, and moments of effective spectacle. But it too often feels at odds with itself, unable to reconcile its competing ambitions into a cohesive, satisfying whole.



Discover more from RGM

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

You Might Also Like

Popular Posts

"Sunrise on the Reaping" pairs stunning design with crowded storytelling, familiar tropes, and excessive connections.
This week brings a mix of fresh albums and hot singles from YFN Lucci, Conway The Machine & The Kid LAROI.
Don Toliver announces "NITROUS" for December 4, setting up another major release before 2026 ends.
If we’re to judge from the soundtrack, The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is going to be a fantastic film.